12 Critical Reasons Small and Mid-sized Businesses Need Cyber Insurance

Cyber threats have become one of the most significant risks facing businesses today. The financial and operational consequences can be devastating from ransomware attacks to data breaches. Traditional insurance policies do not typically cover these risks, leaving companies vulnerable to cyber incidents. This gap has led to the emergence of cyber insurance, a specialized policy designed to protect businesses from financial losses resulting from cyberattacks. As cyber threats grow more sophisticated, companies must understand how cyber insurance works and what it covers. Without insurance, businesses may struggle to recover from these expenses.

1. Small and Mid-Sized Businesses Are Prime Targets for Cyberattacks

Many small and mid-sized business owners assume cybercriminals only target large enterprises. However, cybercriminals often see small and mid-sized businesses as easier targets due to their weaker cybersecurity defenses and limited IT resources. Without protection, even a single breach can be financially devastating.

A successful cyberattack can disrupt operations and cause severe financial damage. Many of these businesses lack the financial resources to recover from data breaches or ransomware attacks. Cyber insurance helps mitigate these risks by covering data recovery, business interruption, and legal expenses. This financial safety net ensures small and mid-sized businesses can continue operating after an attack.

2. Cyberattacks Can Cause Severe Financial Losses

A cyberattack can result in significant direct and indirect costs for a small business. Direct costs include hiring forensic investigators, restoring compromised systems, and legal fees. Indirect costs, such as downtime, lost customers, and reputational damage, can be just as damaging. Without cyber insurance, businesses must cover these expenses out-of-pocket.

Small and mid-sized businesses often struggle to recover from the financial impact of a cyberattack. Research shows that 60% of small businesses close within six months of a cyberattack. The financial burden is often too great for smaller companies to handle alone. Cyber insurance helps ensure businesses have the financial support needed to recover.

Cyber insurance policies can also compensate for lost revenue due to business interruption. If a ransomware attack locks a business out of its systems, operations may come to a halt. Business interruption coverage helps replace lost income while systems are restored, which is essential for keeping businesses afloat during recovery.

3. Data Breaches Can Lead to Legal and Regulatory Consequences

Businesses that handle sensitive customer data are subject to strict data protection laws. Regulations such as GDPR, HIPAA, and CCPA require companies to safeguard personal and financial information. Failure to comply can result in hefty fines, legal penalties, and lawsuits. Insurance can help businesses manage these legal risks.

Beyond financial penalties, businesses must also notify affected customers promptly in the event of a breach. Customer notification requirements can be costly and complex, depending on the size of the breach. Cyber insurance covers customer notification costs and credit monitoring services for individuals affected by the incident. These measures enable businesses to maintain compliance while protecting their customer relationships.

4. Ransomware Attacks Are on the Rise

Ransomware attacks have surged, crippling businesses and demanding hefty ransom payments. Cybercriminals use malware to encrypt company data, making it inaccessible until a ransom is paid. Cyber insurance helps businesses cover ransom payments, negotiation fees, and the costs associated with data recovery.

Many small and mid-sized businesses lack the expertise to handle ransomware negotiations. Paying a ransom does not guarantee data recovery, and engaging with cybercriminals can be a risky endeavor. Insurance policies often include provisions for cybersecurity specialists to assist with negotiations and decryption efforts. Having expert guidance can prevent costly mistakes and reduce downtime.

Beyond paying ransoms, businesses must also restore their systems and investigate how the attack happened. Cyber insurance covers incident response, forensic investigations, and IT recovery efforts. This ensures businesses can identify vulnerabilities and strengthen their defenses after an attack. Preventing future incidents is just as important as recovering from the current one.

5. Cyber Insurance Helps Cover Third-Party Liability

If a business suffers a cyberattack, it may also impact third parties, including customers, vendors, and partners. If sensitive customer data is stolen, companies may be held liable for financial losses. Cyber insurance provides liability coverage for lawsuits, settlements, and legal defense costs. This protection ensures businesses can handle third-party claims effectively.

Third-party liability is significant for businesses that store financial data or personal information. A single breach could lead to multiple lawsuits from affected customers or business partners. Legal expenses can quickly escalate beyond what a small business can afford without insurance. Liability coverage ensures companies can defend against claims without draining their resources.

6. Cyber Insurance Supports Incident Response and Recovery

When a cyberattack occurs, businesses must respond quickly to minimize damage and restore operations. Many small and mid-sized businesses lack the in-house expertise to handle forensic investigations, containment, and system recovery. Cyber insurance often provides access to incident response teams who assist with investigations and remediation. Having expert support ensures that businesses can recover more quickly and prevent further damage.

Incident response is crucial in determining how an attack happened and what data was compromised. A well-handled response reduces legal liabilities and reputational harm. Cyber insurance policies often cover the costs of hiring cybersecurity experts, forensic analysts, and legal consultants. This support allows businesses to focus on recovery rather than struggling with response efforts.

7. Supply Chain Attacks Are Increasing

Cybercriminals are increasingly targeting third-party vendors and suppliers to breach larger organizations. A supply chain attack could expose sensitive data if a small business relies on cloud services, payment processors, or IT providers.

One major challenge is that businesses cannot always control their vendors' security practices. A breach in the supply chain can disrupt operations, expose sensitive data, and create compliance risks. Cyber insurance offers protection against third-party negligence, enabling businesses to recover from vendor-related incidents. Strong contract agreements with vendors should also be in place to define security responsibilities.

8. Social Engineering Attacks Are Becoming More Sophisticated

Cybercriminals increasingly use social engineering tactics to manipulate employees into disclosing sensitive information. Phishing emails, fraudulent phone calls, and impersonation attacks deceive employees into disclosing passwords, financial information, or system access credentials. Cyber insurance can cover financial losses resulting from fraudulent transactions caused by social engineering scams.

One of the most damaging forms of social engineering is business email compromise (BEC). In these attacks, criminals impersonate executives or vendors to request fraudulent wire transfers. Cyber insurance provides financial reimbursement for fraudulent transactions and legal costs associated with social engineering scams.

9. Cyber Insurance Can Help Secure Business Loans and Contracts

Lenders and business partners increasingly require companies to have cyber insurance as part of their risk management strategies. Companies that handle financial data, healthcare records, or sensitive client information may need cyber insurance to qualify for contracts. Without proper coverage, businesses risk losing valuable partnerships and funding opportunities.

Many organizations require vendors to demonstrate cybersecurity readiness before signing agreements. Cyber insurance often proves that a company is prepared for potential cyber threats. Some industries, including finance and healthcare, mandate cyber insurance for regulatory compliance. Having a policy in place can improve business credibility and competitiveness.

10. Cyber Insurance Protects Against Insider Threats

Cyber threats don’t always come from external hackers—insider threats are a growing concern for businesses. Disgruntled employees, careless staff, or compromised user accounts can lead to data breaches and financial losses. Cyber insurance helps cover damages caused by internal security incidents, whether intentional or accidental.

Even well-meaning employees can accidentally expose sensitive information. Sending confidential data to the wrong recipient, falling for phishing scams, or misconfiguring security settings can lead to costly breaches. Cyber insurance provides financial protection while businesses investigate and remediate internal security lapses.

Malicious insiders may also steal proprietary information, manipulate financial records, or sabotage IT systems. These incidents can be challenging to detect and expensive to resolve. Cyber insurance covers legal costs, forensic investigations, and recovery efforts associated with insider attacks. Businesses should also implement access controls and activity monitoring to reduce insider threats.

11. Cybercriminals Are Targeting Cloud Services

Many small and mid-sized businesses rely on cloud-based services for data storage, communications, and applications. While cloud providers offer security features, data breaches and misconfigurations continue to be common attack vectors. Cyber insurance protects businesses against financial losses resulting from cloud security failures, enabling them to recover from downtime or data breaches.

Cybercriminals gain access by targeting misconfigured cloud databases, weak authentication systems, and exposed credentials. If a cloud provider experiences an outage or breach, businesses may lose critical files, customer records, or operational data. Cyber insurance covers lost revenue, system recovery costs, and legal defense expenses resulting from cloud-related incidents.

12. The Cost of Cyber Insurance Is Rising—Getting Coverage Early Is Critical

As cyber threats escalate, insurance premiums are increasing due to the growing number of claims. Businesses that wait too long to obtain cyber insurance may face higher premiums or limited coverage options. Investing in a policy now helps lock in affordable rates and comprehensive protection before costs rise further.

Insurance providers are tightening their underwriting requirements, making it harder for businesses with poor cybersecurity practices to qualify. Businesses without multi-factor authentication (MFA), endpoint security, or employee training may be denied coverage or charged higher premiums. Implementing strong cybersecurity measures improves insurability and reduces policy costs.

Get the Right Partner for Your Small or Mid-Sized Business

Small and mid-sized businesses face increasing cyber risks, including ransomware, phishing, cloud security breaches, and insider threats. Cyber insurance is critical for protecting against financial losses, legal liabilities, and reputational damage. Without coverage, businesses may struggle to recover from a single cyber incident. CompassMSP offers expert cybersecurity solutions and guidance to small and mid-sized companies. Contact us today to protect your business from financial loss and evolving cyber risks.

Join Us for Our Next Webinar:

You're invited to join us on April 17th at 1 PM EST for "Cyber Insurance in 2025:  What Small and Mid-Sized Businesses Need to Know to Stay Protected."